• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Before Header

Michelle's blog

Food allergy and food intolerance, freefrom foods, electrosensitivity, this and that...

  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • FreeFrom Food Awards
  • Foods Matter
  • Walks & Gardens
  • Salon Music
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • FreeFrom Food Awards
  • Foods Matter
  • Walks & Gardens
  • Salon Music

Fashions in Health

15/05/2011 //  by Michelle Berridale Johnson//  1 Comment

I felt, as I read the headline ‘Eating less salt does not cut heart risks, study says…’ my mother’s ghost hovering over me, finger wagging.

‘You health nuts,’ she accused me, back in the 1990s when the Mediterranean diet had just become all the rage, ‘Ten years ago you all told me that I shouldn’t eat olive oil because it was too fatty – now you are telling me that it is the healthiest food out! I am not going to pay any attention to you – none of you have a clue what you are talking about!’

Well, whole food policies have been built over the last ten years, on the belief that we were all eating far too much salt which would inevitably lead to us all suffering strokes and heart attacks and now here is a Belgian researcher (Dr Jan Staessen, of the University of Leuven to be precise) telling us that this is a load of nonsense and that in his study, those who consumed the least salt had a 3% higher chance of dying from a heart attack than those who consumed the most!

Well, it is a little more complicated than that – and this is of course only one study (if you want to read a more detailed report click here) – but it does make you wonder… And this is not the first time that advice has been turned on its head.

I recently heard an eminent allergist slagging off colleagues who were still recommending that infants from atopic families and their mothers should not consume peanuts under the age of two as that was now ‘old’ advice and ‘the latest research showed’ that one should start inducing tolerance early – or, hang on, was it the other way around? Or was that last month? God help the parents of atopic children who may indeed be peanut allergic as the advice is now very confusing. Very well meant and very eminent, but still very confusing. See the FSA advice on eating peanuts during pregnancy, breast feeding and early childhood.

It is easy to carp but if we are humble – or realistic – enough to accept that we still know extraordinarily little about the body and how it functions, it is not surprising that each time we learn a little more, our understanding of the whole changes. It is a bit like doing a jig saw without a picture – you get one bit right and on that basis make all kinds of assumptions about the rest of the picture only to discover, when you fit the next group of pieces, that you had actually got it all wrong. Fine for a jigsaw – not so fine when you are dealing with the health of whole populations.

In introducing the excellent BSEM conference on vaccinations last March, Dr Dovid Freed pointed out that until very recently doctors would never have had the temerity to tell you how to stay healthy; they confined themselves to doing their best to make you better once you got ill. Given their dodgy record on nutritional advice (setting aside their policies on prophylactic medication – aka vaccinations) maybe governments should do the same?

 

Category: Alternative/Complementary HealthTag: BSEM conference, Dr Dovid Freed, Dr Jan Staessen, Food/health policy, Mediterranean diet, salt

Previous Post: « Getting Rid of Peanut Residue
Next Post: Food Intolerance – or ‘Just’ Anxiety?… »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Janet Woodward

    16/05/2011 at 08:17

    Yes, the advice changes, whats relevant and shouted from the roof tops this month, might not be the same as next month.
    No wonder we are suffering from “havent got a clue and will have to muddle through-itis”. Information is more readily available through the media and the Internet. Overload…and panic!!

    People differ…and yes trends can also run in families.
    One size doesnt fit all….and its unrealistic to suggest that it does.
    What we have to do…is be aware…and vigilant in our own families, and act accordingly. Thats about as good as it can get.
    What we do …desperately …need to do..is get the medics to listen….
    Mission impossible….?

    Janet

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Colliding with a new reality – the hazards of low vision
  • Call for adult allergy sufferers
  • The vegan/allergy labelling issue
  • A gluten free Christmas just could be delicious – not a penance!
  • A food fad won’t kill you – an allergy will

Search this blog

ARCHIVES

Blogroll

  • Allergy Insight
  • Better brains, naturally
  • For Ever FreeFrom
  • Free From (gluten)
  • Freefrom Food Awards
  • Gluten-free Mrs D
  • Natural Health Worldwide
  • Pure Health Clinic
  • Skins Matter
  • The Helminthic Therapy Wiki
  • Truly Gluten Free
  • What Allergy?

TOPICS

A food fad won’t kill you – an allergy will

There has been a predictable outcry in the allergy world this week’s in response to Rachel Johnson’s piece in Thursday’s Evening Standard on ‘dietary requirements’ and food fads. Being charitable, I am assuming that she has never suffered from or lived with someone with a food allergy. However, I do have some sympathy with her …

Bioplastics – a solution or part of the problem?

Everyday Plastic is a social enterprise group using accessible learning and publicity campaigns to reduce the amount of plastics used daily in our society. It was founded by its current director Daniel Webb who, having moved to Margate in Kent in 2016, was horrified to discover that there were no plastic recycling options on offer.  …

FreeFrom Christmas Awards – the Winners

Since they were launched two years ago the FreeFrom Christmas Awards have been a great success. And how lucky are ‘freefrom-ers’ these days!  From Advent calendars to gifts, party food to Christmas dinner, there is no longer any need for them to miss out. Indeed, the whole family can happily eat freefrom and never know …

Do not extradite Julian Assange to the US

Julian Assange is being sought by the current US administration for publishing US government documents which exposed war crimes and human rights abuses. The politically motivated charges represent an unprecedented attack on press freedom and the public’s right to know – seeking to criminalise basic journalistic activity. Assange is facing a 175-year sentence for publishing …

What to believe – applying critical thought

For the average citizen evaluating the claims made for cure all – or even improve all – health products and procedures has always been difficult. Not only is it an area in which we have minimal expertise but most of us have a vested interest in finding a miracle intervention that will solve our health …

Could wireless monitoring devices be killing racehorses?

Regular readers may remember that back in August last year I alerted you to a posting on Arthur Firstenberg’s Cellphone Task Force site about phone masts and bird flu. Could there be a connection between the fact that the two wildlife sites in Holland and Northern France which had suffered catastrophic bird flu deaths were …

Site Footer

Copyright © 2025 · Michelle's Blog · Michelle Berridale Johnson · Site design by DigitalJen·