• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Before Header

Michelle's blog

Food allergy and food intolerance, freefrom foods, electrosensitivity, this and that...

  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • FreeFrom Food Awards
  • Foods Matter
  • Walks & Gardens
  • Salon Music
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • FreeFrom Food Awards
  • Foods Matter
  • Walks & Gardens
  • Salon Music

A ‘gluten-free scam’, the ensuing rants and terminological confusion

08/11/2013 //  by Michelle Berridale Johnson//  8 Comments

Gluten free aisleJulia Llewellyn Smith has caused a predictable storm with her article in yesterday’s  Telegraph, The Great Gluten-free Scam. In essence she is saying (backed by coeliac nutritionist, Ian Marber) that gluten is being demonised. It is not the cause of every ill from which you suffer. Bloating, pain, diarrhoea, fatigue etc could be caused by the yeast in the bread, the manufacturing process, the other foods that you eat, your life style  or half a dozen other culprits – all of which is perfectly true. (See the very interesting research carried out some years ago by the University of Surrey which showed that 50% of those who complained of having a food intolerance got better when put on a healthy-eating diet for two weeks.)

She also points out that gluten free food is more expensive (which it is, but usually with perfectly good reason – see my blog last week) and that it is not healthier than non gluten-free food – indeed quite the opposite. This is certainly true of some, but not all, g-f foods.

However, she wraps all of these perfectly valid points in some rather inflammatory prose:

Novak Djokovic, who attributes his gluten-free regime to transforming his tennis, now has his dog following it (though Andy Murray who beat him in this year’s Wimbledon final says the same diet made him “lose strength”.) (Not strictly true as, if you can be bothered to read the book, going gluten-free was only one of a whole range of healthy eating and living measures that Djokovic adopted.)

Tesco peddles a heart-warming story of how its former chief executive Sir Terry Leahy appointed the mother of a child who suffered from several food allergies to set up his “free-from” range, after she wrote to him complaining about the lack of suitable foods available. (As it happens, true, although the mother in question, Patricia Wheway, was already a buyer at Tesco, so not quite as heart-warming as it sounds.)

Predictably, there has been a flood of more or less peeved (and amusing) rants from the coeliac/gluten-free community focusing on Ms Llewellyn’s Smith’s more inflammatory comments. They would make good morning coffee reading for those who are interested. Try:

Alex at Food Allergy and Intolerance Ink

The Happy Coeliac (quoted by Alex)

The Gluten Dude (quoted by The Happy Coeliac….)

Fuelled for Fitness (not quoted by anyone…)

 

I was just about to post this when a link to an article on the Huffington Post plopped into my in-box:

Gluten Allergies Don’t Exist, Says Specialist Doctor – and the UK’s leading charity, Allergy UK agrees!

“It was shocking to me, the amount of misinformation that is available to the general public,” said Dr Stukus, an allergist at Nationwide Children’s Hospital and assistant professor of pediatrics at Ohio State University. At the top of his list is people claiming to be allergic to bread…….”

Oh dear….. I know that it is frustrating, as a professional, to have everyone constantly using the terminology of your trade incorrectly, but why can’t medics just lighten up a bit!!

When the average man/woman in the street talks about an ‘allergy’ they are using the term in the way in which it originally was conceived – an inappropriate response to a perfectly harmless substance. They are not remotely interested in whether it is immune mediated, involves IgE antibodies, has an immediate response or a delayed response – they only know that when they eat/breathe/touch certain things they don’t feel well.

So please could the medical profession just focus on their ill health and what might have caused it rather than wittering on endlessly about whether or not they are calling it by the right name!

If you are up for more discussion of the subject, check in to Alex’s Food Allergy and Intolerance Ink blog here.

Category: Allergies, Coeliac/celiac disease, FreeFrom Food, Gluten-freeTag: allergy definitions, bloating and pain, cost of gluten-free food, diarrhoea, Dr Stukus assistant professor of pediatrics at Ohio State University, Food Allergy and Intolerance Ink, Fuelled for Fitness, gluten-free foods unhealthier than normal food, Huffington Post, Ian Marber, Julia Llewellyn Smith, Novak Djokovic and gluten, Patricia Wheway, Telegraph, Tesco and freefrom, The Gluten Dude, The Happy Coeliac, University of Surrey, yeast in bread causes bloating

Previous Post: « Is scratching eczema a form of self harm?
Next Post: Tactile tableware, vanilla tapenade, 38 brands of gin and conversing in real time with the grower of your Shisito peppers… »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. jeemboh

    08/11/2013 at 19:54

    Specialists in every field rely on abstruse terminology to set them apart from the rest of us. Look at lawyers and financiers. Its not just their white coats that allow consultants to charge fat fees!

  2. Alex G

    09/11/2013 at 15:12

    Re: ‘gluten allergy doesn’t exist’ – I suppose allergists are allowed their pet peeves (which is what seemed to have motivated Dr Stukus to make a point of this), but perhaps it was naive of him to not consider how the media may run with what he was saying … predictably, the end result is the free from / food sensitive community suffers and gets a bashing!

  3. Michelle

    09/11/2013 at 15:44

    I am afraid that I don’t think allergists are allowed their pet peeves. Their job in life is to help a community that has a hard enough time trying to improve their health anyhow without their doctors castigating them for getting the terminology wrong! Less time worrying about what the problem is called and more time trying to solve it please…..

  4. Caleigh

    11/11/2013 at 17:29

    I think it was the tone of Ms Llewellyn Smith’s article that prompted the rants. I felt quite uncomfortable reading it! There were some excellent points, it was a shame they got lost in the inflammatory language.

    Unfortunately, the gluten free diet has become a bit of an Aunt Sally recently and it’s the people who live with it every day who get caught in the firing line. I agree with you, Michelle, less emphasis on pedantry, more effort into treating sufferers!

  5. Ruth Holroyd

    13/11/2013 at 12:31

    I guess also we should consider that he was interviewed here and someone chose that heading. It may not have been Dr Stukus himself. Headings for articles are often sensationalist but this one is unfortunate. The fact that it is technically true is irrelevant. The words people will see here are ‘allergies’ ‘don’t’ and ‘exist’. Which is not a good message. I am all in favour of raising awareness and explaining away all those myths that confuse everyone. Like the fact that eggs are not dairy… my favourite pet peev. But the whole allergy industry suffers here. Some will click through, read the article and understand the point being made but many will just read the headling and draw their own conclusions -sadly.

  6. Michelle

    13/11/2013 at 13:50

    Sadly, you are absolutely right, Ruth. But, as we all know, sensationalist headlines grab readers so I fear that we have to put up with them. Just hope that enough people are intrigued/irritated enough by the headline to actually read the article!

  7. Alex G

    13/11/2013 at 19:47

    All I meant was that he’s allowed his pet peeve – but whether he should be sharing it, broadcasting it, confiding it with a journalist … that’s another matter entirely. I may be playing devil’s advocate, but to put oneself in his shoes – it must be deeply frustrating to be confronted with the often wild and crazy misinformation about sensitivities on the web, and unpicking poor diagnoses from unqualified people / dodgy tests, or indeed self-diagnoses, when you’re a dedicated, long-standing allergist – I’ve interviewed enough specialists to know how much of a problem this can be. If indeed he has been irritated by this, then I have some sympathy, I’m afraid. It was certain sections of the media who inflated his point, tabloid style, and introduced the whole ‘all in the head’ dimension. (He would have had zero to do with the headline, Ruth – and I don’t think he was interviewed, just extracts taken from his presentation / talk.) If it weren’t for the populist media, and this had been covered, rationally, in the medical media, we all could have been having a sensible discussion about terminology and wheat proteins and reactions etc … Instead, many people are going to think the whole GF ‘thing’ is a fiction. I’m getting mad all over again!!

Trackbacks

  1. list 170 | My Blog says:
    10/11/2013 at 15:06

    […] http://www.foodsmatter.com/blog/a-gluten-free-scam-the-ensuing-rants-and-terminological-confusion/ […]

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • The Shape of Skin
  • FreeFrom Food Awards judging in times of COVID
  • FAB Research – blindness in pre term babies
  • #Speak Up for Allergies
  • Novel food proteins – do they pose a risk to food allergics?

Search this blog

ARCHIVES

Blogroll

  • Allergy Insight
  • Better brains, naturally
  • For Ever FreeFrom
  • Free From (gluten)
  • Freefrom Food Awards
  • Gluten-free Mrs D
  • Natural Health Worldwide
  • Pure Health Clinic
  • Skins Matter
  • The Helminthic Therapy Wiki
  • Truly Gluten Free
  • What Allergy?

TOPICS

Novel food proteins – do they pose a risk to food allergics?

Last month the Anaphylaxis Campaign hosted a fascinating webinar with Carole Bingley from Reading Scientific Services Ltd (RSSL) and Hazel Gowland of Allergy Action. They looked at both plant-based and novel proteins and the risk that they might pose for the allergic community. Carole Bingley, Technical Specialist Product Innovation, RSSL The drivers for the growth …

The dairy wars

An excellent recent post on Alex Gazzola’s AllergyInsight blog covers several subjects (including a recent Anaphylaxis Campaign webinar on novel proteins on which more anon) but homes in on the current battle between the vegan and dairy lobbies, both claiming the moral high grand in the environmental debate. The truth is, of course, that if …

In memory of Pat Schooling

It is with great sadness that I have to report the death on January 20th of Pat Schooling, the Director and moving spirit behind Action Against Allergy.  She was 93. AAA, founded by Amelia Nathan Hill in 1978, was the first charity to be set up to support those with undiagnosed food allergy and intolerance. …

FSA – on the allergy case

You might well have thought that COVID concerns had taken over all branches of government activity – but not so. The Foods Standards Agency, while noting the issues, has refused to be distracted from its Food Hypersensitivity work. What is also good to realise – although I suspect that few do – is that all …

Homeopathy – a second string to our vaccination bow?

Cuba has always had a very individualistic– and on the whole very successful – approach to public and population health. The hard line socialist nature of their politics, especially in early days after the revolution, resulted in very high levels of education and medical care – but also in isolation from much of the developed …

Sad, sad news

Yesterday evening, Lisa Acton – co founder, with her husband John Burke, of the Irish FreeFrom Food Awards – finally lost a long and heroic battle with cancer. To my regret I had only met her a few times. A couple of years ago when John brought the whole family to a FreeFrom Food Awards …

Site Footer

Signup for the latest news from the blog

Regular updates on Food – policy, allergy, intolerance – and other unrelated matters…

Thank you!

You have successfully joined our subscriber list.

.

Copyright © 2021 · Michelle's Blog · Michelle Berridale Johnson · Site design by DigitalJen·