• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Before Header

Michelle's blog

Food allergy and food intolerance, freefrom foods, electrosensitivity, this and that...

  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • FreeFrom Food Awards
  • Foods Matter
  • Walks & Gardens
  • Salon Music
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • FreeFrom Food Awards
  • Foods Matter
  • Walks & Gardens
  • Salon Music

Further lessons for allergy sufferers

14/11/2018 //  by Michelle Berridale Johnson//  1 Comment

Huge media coverage was given to the inquest into the death of Natasha Ednan Laperouse as a result of eating sesame seeds in an unlabelled Pret baguette. Yet the inquest into the death of Megan Lee in 2017 from eating a takeaway Indian which contained peanuts appears to have attracted relatively little attention. But, for the allergy community, Megan’s death raises equally important, if different, issues from Natasha’s.

Natasha died because the Pret baguette that she ate included sesame seeds, to which she knew she had a potentially anaphylactic allergy. Since the baguette did not carry ingredients labelling (thanks to the loophole in the regulations which meant that the baguette was not required to) there is no way that she could have known that it contained sesame seeds. Sesame seeds are an unlikely ingredient in a baguette. On top of a bread product – yes – but inside a baguette? Not really.

There are those who might question the wisdom of eating any prepackaged food product without knowing exactly what it contains if you have a life threatening allergy but it certainly seems that in Natasha’s case it was essentially Pret who were at fault.

Megan’s case was very different.

In Megan’s case, The Royal Spice takeaway which sent her a meal ‘littered’ with peanut protein was most definitely to blame. As Judge Mrs Justice Yip said at the inquest said ‘The Royal Spice had no systems or processes to manage allergen control. The menu contained no information about allergens. No record was kept of the ingredients used in dishes.’  They also had a poor hygiene record and failed  discharge several of their statutory duties to their employers.  So guilty on all counts.

But….

Warning

When they ordered the takeaway, Megan’s friend had posted ”prawns and nuts’ in a comments section of the JustEat website near to a separate area about allergies’.
Mrs Justice Yip told jurors: ‘It is a matter of interpretation, and so a matter for you, whether that was enough to put the business on notice of Megan’s allergy to nuts.’ Although it does not in anyway exempt the Royal Spice from guilt, was merely putting ‘prawn and peanuts’ in a comments section enough warning to any eaterie that that customer had a (potentially fatal) allergy to prawns and peanuts?

Reading through the reports from our judges for the FreeFrom Eating Out Awards, virtually all of whom either have, or have children who have, serious allergies – the answer would be a resounding ‘no’.  They would make it very clear when ordering that they had an allergy and, unless they knew the eatery well, would want verbal reassurance that their instructions and been understood and would be followed.

No to takeaways

And…. None of them would dream of ordering from a takeaway unless they knew it very, very well. Takeways are notorious (the Royal Spice was not unusual) for having poor hygiene, bad employment practices and no idea at all about allergens.

And no to Indian food

One for the glories of Indian food is the many layers of spicing, the long, slow cooked sauces, the complex bread products. All ideal sites for contamination and perfect dishes in which allergens can hide and be all but undetectable. So once again, unless they knew the Indian restaurant extremely well and had absolute confidence in its allergen protocols, no seriously allergic person would eat in an Indian restaurant, let alone order from an Indian takeaway.

All of which would suggest that although the Royal Spice was very much at fault in this case, Megan had not been handling her allergy very responsibly – but…..

How serious is your allergy?

If you read on in the Mirror‘s report of the inquest, Megan’s mother said:

‘Neither of us (her parents) were aware that Megan’s allergies could have lead to her death and we always believed, from what we were told, that she had mild allergies…..
She has not had many reactions to food but had previously eaten a prawn cracker and had a reaction although she was not taken to the hospital…..
We have always been very careful with food and taken care to see what ingredients are in the food we are eating….
As a family if we ever ordered takeaway food it would always be the same place. As a rule, Megan would never have any sauce from a takeaway…..

She has previously eaten all of the items ordered, except for the peshwari naan, and has never suffered an allergic reaction. I don’t believe Megan would know what a peshwari naan is…..’

So Megan was not being irresponsible as far as her allergy was concerned – she just didn’t know that the ‘mild’ allergy that she knew she had could, with no warning at all, turn into a life threatening allergy, or even in her case, a fatal one. Only in ordering from a takeaway that she didn’t know could she be seen as behaving even remotely irresponsibly. But if she had eaten all of those dishes before without incident, and if she did not think that she had a serious allergy, then that really should not have been an issue.

The moral of which has to be that no allergic reaction, however apparently mild, can be taken lightly. There is always the possibility that it will develop without warning, into a serious allergy. So however insignificant the reaction may appear to have been, the sufferer needs to be aware of the risks, to carry the appropriate medication and to know how to use it. And, if they are female, they need to be sure that the adrenaline autoinjector that they are given has a long enough needle. (See my previous blog on this subject.)

close

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Category: Allergies, Dairy-free, Food, FreeFrom Food, Gluten-free, Peanut allergyTag: FreeFrom Eating Out Awards, Just Eat website, length of needle in autoinjectors, Megan Lee, Megan lee dies of peanut allergy, Most takeaways have poor hygiene record, Mrs Justice Yip, Natasha Ednan-Laperouse, Peanut/treenut allergy, Pret baguette, Royal spice takeaway, Royal Spice takeaway found guild to chug Megan Lee's death

Previous Post: « Do the guidelines protect us – or do they pose a serious risk to human health?
Next Post: A celebration of James’ life and work »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Thomas Ogren

    14/11/2018 at 22:11

    Food allergies and food intolerances more often than not have their roots in pollen-allergy. People are locally exposed to excessive pollen of some species, and then because of cross-reactivity between proteins in that pollen and proteins in certain foods, suddenly a food problem is started.
    The plant pollen and the food itself need not be directly related (per genus/species) because if there are similar-shaped proteins, then the body may mistakenly recognize the shape of the food protein as an allergen.
    The point is this: Yes, we need to do more to avoid any and ALL deaths from food allergies…we need to be more vigilant on this. At the same time, if we just keep right on planting more and more highly allergenic, pollen-intensive city trees (and shrubs) then we continue to promote the whole pollen-food-allergy connection.
    We need to hold accountable those who are in charge of planting city trees. We need to demand that they stop planting so many wind-pollinated species, or male-clones of these wind-pollinated species.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • FSA – on the allergy case
  • Homeopathy – a second string to our vaccination bow?
  • Sad, sad news
  • Are COVID vaccines safe for those with allergies?
  • Disastrous Brexit fallout for medical cannabis users

Search this blog

ARCHIVES

Blogroll

  • Allergy Insight
  • Better brains, naturally
  • For Ever FreeFrom
  • Free From (gluten)
  • Freefrom Food Awards
  • Gluten-free Mrs D
  • Natural Health Worldwide
  • Pure Health Clinic
  • Skins Matter
  • The Helminthic Therapy Wiki
  • Truly Gluten Free
  • What Allergy?

TOPICS

Disastrous Brexit fallout for medical cannabis users

Thanks to the tireless campaigning of a group of  ‘epilepsy mothers’, lead by Hannah Deacon, the mother of Alfie Dingley, and her consultant, neurologist Professor Mike Barnes, a change in the law in 2018 allowed the prescription of medical cannabis for children with certain rare types of epilepsy, those in chronic pain and for those …

The trouble about gluten-free oats

Oats are delicious – oats are nutritious – they contain high levels of vitamins, minerals and antioxidants and are an excellent source of fibre – they do not contain the protein gliadin, the gluten fraction that coeliacs need to avoid – they add texture to gluten free baking and are easy to cook with. Few …

Happy, if distanced, Christmas!

After this very strange and, for many people, horribly difficult year I wanted to wish you all a very peaceful, safe, healthy and hopefully happy Christmas. And offer you a little allergic chortle. Those of you who used to receive the FoodsMatter magazine will remember all of Christopher’s wonderful allergy related cartoons – the caption …

Good news for those with peanut allergy

The news may be grim on the virus front but there have been two bits of good news this month for those with peanut allergy. Earlier in the month The Journal of Allergy and Immunology: In Practice reported on on a trial which demonstrated that peanut oral immunotherapy is still effective after one year of …

Is it time to subject Vitamin C to serious scientific scrutiny?

Ever since 1970 when the Nobel Laureate Linus Pauling claimed that gram dose vitamin C supplementation could prevent and alleviate the common cold, the argument has rumbled on – how effective can vitamin C supplementation be for respiratory infections both mild (such as the common cold) or more acute (pneumonia and, maybe, COVID19). The evidence …

Share a meal

Yes, indeed – what a lovely thing to be able to do – and one that we have been deprived of for all too long. But, we don’t have to be. Over lockdown my good friend Sarah Stacey, who lives in a tiny village in Dorset, started cooking meals for a poorly neighbour. Talking to …

Copyright © 2021 · Michelle's Blog · Michelle Berridale Johnson · Site design by DigitalJen·