• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Before Header

Michelle's blog

Food allergy and food intolerance, freefrom foods, electrosensitivity, this and that...

  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • FreeFrom Food Awards
  • Foods Matter
  • Walks & Gardens
  • Salon Music
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • FreeFrom Food Awards
  • Foods Matter
  • Walks & Gardens
  • Salon Music

FreeFrom Food Awards judging – Week One….

29/01/2017 //  by Michelle Berridale Johnson//  Leave a Comment

This is what we like to see – a room full of judges fully focused on the job in hand! And it is some job this year, with well over 500 products to judge over the two week period.

I am also delighted to be able to report that the standard of the entries so far has been really exceptional – and really exciting. We had some genuinely innovative products entered into the Innovation Award – which has not always been the case! (For more on her faves in the Innovation category see GlutenFree Mrs D’s blog here.) And we had nearly 50 products entered into the our new ‘No Top 14 allergens’ category! We had thought that we would get about ten so we were gobsmacked! (For ForEverFreeFrom’s  faves see Benjamin’s blog here.) Obviously, we can give no hint of what might even get as far as the shortlist yet but, there will be a lot!!

Our judging system, which has proved pretty reliable over the years, remains essentially the same.  Judges are given a sheet for each product which is that entrant’s entry form with just their name removed. All other information remains as they input it so that, in theory, it is correct and we cannot  mess it up. Well, that is the theory. In fact, entrants are not good at filling in forms and for around 25% of the products in each category we have to refer back to the pack to see what the pack actually says, that being, of course, the important bit.

All products are judged ‘blind’ – in other words the judges do not get to see the packaging, just the food. Here are Catherine and Katherine preparing the sweet ‘Store cupboard’ products. (For the GlutenFree Centre’s assessment of the Store Cupboard category see here.)

The judges need to assess each product on the basis of its appearance, aroma, texture and taste. But they also need to take into account its nutritional profile. Many of those eating freefrom food have health issues and therefore we are keen for them to eat healthy products, not those in which the gluten/dairy has just been replaced with extra sugar or fat. We also ask judges to consider whether there is a real need in the freefrom market for this product – do we really need another gluten free chocolate brownie, no matter how delicious?  Also, how difficult it is to make. Making a good gluten-free chocolate brownie, even a gluten and milk-free chocolate brownie is not a major test of a manufacturer’s skills and ingenuity whereas making a gluten and milk-free pain au chocolat seriously is!

We ask judges to remain poker faced during this process so as not to influence fellow judges. They are pretty good in the morning but, I must admit that as the day wears on, it gets harder. As you can see Tom Treverton from  the Allergy Show has remain focused here, but Steve Walpole and Gill Jacobs are slightly losing the plot!!

All judges are asked to make comments on the products that could be helpful to the manufacturers (these are fed back after presentation) and to give a mark out of ten. I then take everyone’s top marks, do a very complex bit of mathematics which involves a number of fingers and a calculator, and come up with the highest scorers. However, the highest may not always be (indeed often is not) the winner. So we then have what can be quite a heated argument over what should actually win.  Because we have such a  very diverse range of judges (product developers, chefs, cookery writers, nutritionists, dietitians, bloggers, food writers and a large number of coeliacs and allergy sufferers – or parents of allergic or coeliac children) they can have very different ideas of what they really want from a winning freefrom products. Hence the heated arguments. But hopefully that gives a good perspective both for the freefrom consumer who will buy the products – and for the manufacturers.

So – high points from week 1 for us?

Seeing Besma of Curiously Conscious and a new judge this year, eyeing up a platter of milk-free chocolate mousses that she was actually going to be able to taste, having had to pass up on the previous six offerings as they were only gluten-free and she is dairy free!

Interestingly, a day later it was Jenny Tschiesche, the LunchBoxDoctor and Liz Allan who were feeling deprived as Jenny cannot eat tapioca and Liz cannot eat buckwheat – both extremely popular alternative flours in  a very wide range of gluten-free products. Which only goes to show that no matter how hard to you try cannot please all of the people all of the time!

Other high points?  The amazing range of gluten-free beers. Unfortunately I was too busy pouring to take any pictures of the judges judging, but here are many of the beers lined up pre and post their assessment.

And… The cries of joy from Nathalie of the Intolerant Gourmand when she found a product which would be suitable for Callum, her four year old son who glories in 28 serious allergies, 13 of them anaphylactic! I am not sure whether this magnum look-a-like actually turned out to be Callum safe, but she certainly looks hopeful!

(For more on how to cope with that many allergies – and to end up with a cheerful and healthy little boy who has just completed his first term at school – and acted in the panto! – see the first few articles on this page of the Foods Matter site.)

And of course, the children’ category which we judged yesterday, as always, at Christine Bailey’s house in Reading. But they deserve a blog all to themselves! Coming up….. Meanwhile, on to next week – and remember…

…until you are needed!!

If you want to how more about the FreeFrom Food Awards – check in to the site here.

For some judges’ views on what they have been doing see:
FreeFrom Fairy
FreeFrom Farmhouse
Lunch Box Doctor
Gluten Free Centre
ForEverFreeFrom.com
GlutenFree Mrs D

Category: Allergies, Blogging/social media, Coeliac/celiac disease, Dairy-free, Food, Food/Health Policy, FreeFrom Awards, FreeFrom Food, Gluten-free, Peanut allergyTag: Allergy and FreeFrom Show, Christine Bailey, Curiously Conscious blogspot, Dairy-free Food, Foodsmatter, ForEverFreeFrom blogspot, Freeform Food awards, FreeFrom Food Awards judges, Gluten Free Mrs D, Gluten-free food, GlutenFree Centre, Innovation Award at the FreeFrom Food Awards, Judging for the FreeFrom Food Awards, LunchBoxDoctor, milk-free food, No Top 14 category in the FreeFrom Food Awards, peanut free, Steve Walpole, The Intolerant Gourmand

Previous Post: « FreeFrom Food Awards pending…..
Next Post: FreeFrom Food Awards – Childrens’ category »

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Bioplastics – a solution or part of the problem?
  • FreeFrom Christmas Awards – the Winners
  • Do not extradite Julian Assange to the US
  • What to believe – applying critical thought
  • Could wireless monitoring devices be killing racehorses?

Search this blog

ARCHIVES

Blogroll

  • Allergy Insight
  • Better brains, naturally
  • For Ever FreeFrom
  • Free From (gluten)
  • Freefrom Food Awards
  • Gluten-free Mrs D
  • Natural Health Worldwide
  • Pure Health Clinic
  • Skins Matter
  • The Helminthic Therapy Wiki
  • Truly Gluten Free
  • What Allergy?

TOPICS

Could wireless monitoring devices be killing racehorses?

Regular readers may remember that back in August last year I alerted you to a posting on Arthur Firstenberg’s Cellphone Task Force site about phone masts and bird flu. Could there be a connection between the fact that the two wildlife sites in Holland and Northern France which had suffered catastrophic bird flu deaths were …

New distribution for Dr Joneja’s Histamine books

Dr  Janice Joneja is recognised as a world expert on histamine intolerance – or, to be more accurate, histamine excess. Although intolerance to histamine does exist it is extremely rare. Most of the 1% of the world’s population who are thought to experience histamine related symptoms are actually reacting to an excess of histamine in …

Can words heal?

Sticks and stones may break our bones but words can never hurt us. But is that true? Or, if words cannot literally hurt us, can they either help or hinder us in healing ourselves? This question was raised by a recent article in the Townsend Letter, an e-newsletter for doctors and laymen focusing on alternative …

Veg Power – making it fun

How come the food industry is so successful in persuading us – and our kids – to buy sweet, sugary, unhealthy food instead of healthy veg? Easy…. They are tapping in to the fact that our 10,000 year old DNA still believes that when we come across something sweet (ripe fruit in season, honey up …

Observing the speed limit

Rather grumpily, at 7.45am yesterday morning, I signed in to my on line ‘Speed Awareness Course’ – the alternative I had been offered instead of points and a fine. My crime? Doing 24mph on a 20mph road at 8.30 on a Sunday morning. The course was run by a group called TCC. Our ‘course leader’ …

Heavy Metal and chemical toxicity

Are you worried about the amount of metal and the number of chemicals that we come into contact with on a daily, indeed hourly, basis? Not all of them (at a rough estimate there are over 150,000 chemicals in constant circulation) are bad. Indeed, many are crucial to our daily lives. But many are bad, …

Site Footer

Signup for the latest news from the blog

Regular updates on Food – policy, allergy, intolerance – and other unrelated matters…

Thank you!

You have successfully joined our subscriber list.

.

Copyright © 2023 · Michelle's Blog · Michelle Berridale Johnson · Site design by DigitalJen·