• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Before Header

Michelle's blog

Food allergy and food intolerance, freefrom foods, electrosensitivity, this and that...

  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • FreeFrom Food Awards
  • Foods Matter
  • Walks & Gardens
  • Salon Music
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • FreeFrom Food Awards
  • Foods Matter
  • Walks & Gardens
  • Salon Music

FMTs (otherwise known as poo) to be treated as a drug

20/08/2013 //  by Michelle Berridale Johnson//  5 Comments

Over the past several years there has been a growing interest in Fecal Microbiota Transplantation – the ‘transplantation’ of healthy-bacteria-filled faeces from a well person’s gut  into the guts of those suffering from a range of inflammatory digestive and bowel conditions whose bowel flora have been depleted by their illness. The idea is that the transplanted healthy bacteria colonise the gut, control the inflammation and return all to good working order.

Despite the inevitable ‘eugh!!!’ reaction of many, the treatment does seem to have a good success rate not only in the treatment of inflammatory conditions such as Ulcerative Colitis  or Crohn’s disease, but (of more immediate interest to health authorities) in controlling bacterial infections such as Clostridium Difficile. (See  the various reports collected for us by John Scott here on the FoodsMatter FMT pages.)

But while the outcome of successful transplantation may be good, there are quite reasonable concerns over using faeces, so often the carrier of deadly diseases, as a therapeutic treatment. So it is quite right that the health authorities should take an active interest in what is going on and look to establish controls and standards. But that does not appear to be what is happening – well, in the US anyhow.

According to a letter to the American Gastroenterological Association from the FDA’s Public Health Service in April this year, the FDA proposes that, instead of regulating FMT to ensure that it is properly and hygienically delivered, they will treat it as a drug, ‘for which  an Investigational New Drug (IND) application must be submitted’. A lengthy and immensely costly procedure which would prevent any therapeutic use of faeces until approval had been granted. Now, I wonder why that might be?…..

The pharmaceutical industry has been struggling for some years to come up with new ‘miracle’ drugs, so the microbiome, the trillions of micro-organisms that live in the human body and keep us functioning, is a fertile field of research for them. If they can isolate the bacteria relevant to, say, Clostridium difficile or Ulcerative Colitis, they can patent it and sell it. But if wholesale faecal transplants (which belong to no-one apart from the donor and are not patentable) are allowed to go ahead, and prove successful, then what role for the drug companies? (Take a look at this press release from Second Genome to see where they are going with this research.)

All other considerations aside, the microbiome is staggeringly complex and we, as yet, understand relatively little about it – and even less about the synergistic relationship that its trillions of inhabitants may have with each other. While transplanting the whole population of a health gut, intact, may indeed regenerate the microbiome of an unhealthy gut, we have virtually no idea what effect isolating tiny fractions of that microbiome and applying them selectively may have.

The result of the FDA’s attempt to ‘pharmaeuticalise’ FMT will be that its delivery remains unregulated and open to exploitation as sufferers from the many conditions that appear to benefit from FMT take to the internet to find treatments that they cannot access via their physicians. Scarcely a situation to be desired by anyone.

Category: Alternative/Complementary Health, Conventional Medicine, Food/Health PolicyTag: American Gastroenterological Association, bowel bacteria, bowel flora, Clostridium difficile, complexity of the microbiome, Crohn's disease, faecal transplants, faecal transplants not patentable, FDA's Public Health Service, Fecal Microbiota Transplantation, FMT, FoodsMatter on FMT, healthy bowel bacteria, Investigational New Drug (IND) applications, John Scott, microbiome, Second Genome, synergistic relationship of the microbiome, Ulcerative colitis

Previous Post: « Beware manufacturer ‘freefrom’ lists
Next Post: Blog hiccups »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Ruth Holroyd

    20/08/2013 at 09:31

    WOW, that’s incredibly complex and yet if it works, staggeringly simple. Not sure I’m going to be queueing up just yet, though I guess one would not be presented with a sample of FMT…

  2. Michelle

    20/08/2013 at 10:08

    Well, it does seem to be remarkably effective for all of those really horrible inflammatory gut problems….. By the way – on another ‘euhg!’ but very successful therapy – take a look at John Scott’s latest ‘helminthic success stories’ here. They do seem extraordinarily successful at controlling over active immune systems.

  3. Ruth Holroyd

    20/08/2013 at 10:28

    Ah yes, the helminths. I’m warming to the idea of these. Especially when you read about the incredible benefits both John and others have seen with this therapy. I’m doing really well myself by just avoiding processed foods but if this therapy could help me to be able to explore new foods safely, try different things and eat out without worrying it could be worth trying… in the future maybe. But not the poo thing 🙂

  4. Michelle

    20/08/2013 at 10:55

    Well, your problems are more immune based than digestive so the worms would really be a better bet anyhow!! Save the poo for later!!!

Trackbacks

  1. list 142 | My Blog says:
    02/09/2013 at 00:38

    […] http://www.foodsmatter.com/blog/fmts-otherwise-known-as-poo-to-be-treated-as-a-drug/ […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Colliding with a new reality – the hazards of low vision
  • Call for adult allergy sufferers
  • The vegan/allergy labelling issue
  • A gluten free Christmas just could be delicious – not a penance!
  • A food fad won’t kill you – an allergy will

Search this blog

ARCHIVES

Blogroll

  • Allergy Insight
  • Better brains, naturally
  • For Ever FreeFrom
  • Free From (gluten)
  • Freefrom Food Awards
  • Gluten-free Mrs D
  • Natural Health Worldwide
  • Pure Health Clinic
  • Skins Matter
  • The Helminthic Therapy Wiki
  • Truly Gluten Free
  • What Allergy?

TOPICS

A food fad won’t kill you – an allergy will

There has been a predictable outcry in the allergy world this week’s in response to Rachel Johnson’s piece in Thursday’s Evening Standard on ‘dietary requirements’ and food fads. Being charitable, I am assuming that she has never suffered from or lived with someone with a food allergy. However, I do have some sympathy with her …

Bioplastics – a solution or part of the problem?

Everyday Plastic is a social enterprise group using accessible learning and publicity campaigns to reduce the amount of plastics used daily in our society. It was founded by its current director Daniel Webb who, having moved to Margate in Kent in 2016, was horrified to discover that there were no plastic recycling options on offer.  …

FreeFrom Christmas Awards – the Winners

Since they were launched two years ago the FreeFrom Christmas Awards have been a great success. And how lucky are ‘freefrom-ers’ these days!  From Advent calendars to gifts, party food to Christmas dinner, there is no longer any need for them to miss out. Indeed, the whole family can happily eat freefrom and never know …

Do not extradite Julian Assange to the US

Julian Assange is being sought by the current US administration for publishing US government documents which exposed war crimes and human rights abuses. The politically motivated charges represent an unprecedented attack on press freedom and the public’s right to know – seeking to criminalise basic journalistic activity. Assange is facing a 175-year sentence for publishing …

What to believe – applying critical thought

For the average citizen evaluating the claims made for cure all – or even improve all – health products and procedures has always been difficult. Not only is it an area in which we have minimal expertise but most of us have a vested interest in finding a miracle intervention that will solve our health …

Could wireless monitoring devices be killing racehorses?

Regular readers may remember that back in August last year I alerted you to a posting on Arthur Firstenberg’s Cellphone Task Force site about phone masts and bird flu. Could there be a connection between the fact that the two wildlife sites in Holland and Northern France which had suffered catastrophic bird flu deaths were …

Site Footer

Copyright © 2025 · Michelle's Blog · Michelle Berridale Johnson · Site design by DigitalJen·